First it was the eerie images of barrels leaking on the seafloor not far
from Catalina Island. Then the shocking realization that the nation�s
largest manufacturer of DDT had once used the ocean as a huge dumping
ground � and that as many as half a million barrels of its acid waste had
been poured straight into the water.

Now, scientists have discovered that much of the DDT � which had been
dumped largely in the 1940s and �50s � never broke down. The chemical
remains in its most potent form in startlingly high concentrations, spread
across a wide swath of seafloor larger than the city of San Francisco.

�We still see original DDT on the seafloor from 50, 60, 70 years ago,
which tells us that it�s not breaking down the way that [we] once thought
it should,� said UC Santa Barbara scientist David Valentine, who shared
these preliminary findings Thursday during a research update with more
than 90 people working on the issue. �And what we�re seeing now is that
there is DDT that has ended up all over the place, not just within this
tight little circle on a map that we referred to as Dumpsite Two.�

These revelations confirm some of the science community�s deepest concerns
� and further complicate efforts to understand DDT�s toxic and insidious
legacy in California. Public calls for action have intensified since The
Times reported in 2020 that dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane, banned in
1972, is still haunting the marine environment today. Significant amounts
of DDT-related compounds continue to accumulate in California condors and
local dolphin populations, and a recent study linked the presence of this
once-popular pesticide to an aggressive cancer in sea lions.

With a $5.6-million research boost from Congress, at the urging of Sen.
Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.), numerous federal, state and local agencies
have since joined with scientists and environmental nonprofits to figure
out the extent of the contamination lurking 3,000 feet underwater. (An
additional $5.2 million, overseen by California and USC Sea Grant, will be
distributed this summer to kick off 18 more months of research.)

The findings so far have been one stunning development after another. A
preliminary sonar-mapping effort led by the Scripps Institution of
Oceanography identified at least 70,000 debris-like objects on the
seafloor.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, after combing through thousands
of pages of old records, discovered that other toxic chemicals � as well
as millions of tons of oil drilling waste � had also been dumped decades
ago by other companies in more than a dozen areas off the Southern
California coast.

�When the DDT was disposed, it is highly likely that other materials �
either from the tanks on the barges, or barrels being pushed over the side
of the barges � would have been disposed at the same time,� said John
Lyons, acting deputy director of the EPA�s Region 9 Superfund Division. He
noted that the new science being shared this week is critical to answering
one of the agency�s most burning questions: �Is the contamination moving?
And is it moving in a way that threatens the marine environment or human
health?�

In recent months, Valentine, whose research team had first brought this
decades-old issue back into the public consciousness, has been mapping and
collecting samples of the seafloor between the Los Angeles coast and
Catalina.

Analysis of the sediment so far shows that the most concentrated layer of
DDT is only about 6 centimeters deep � raising questions about just how
easily these still-potent chemicals could be remobilized.

�Trawls, cable lays could reintroduce this stuff back up to the surface,�
Valentine said. �And animals feeding � if a whale goes down and burrows on
the seafloor, that could kick stuff up.�

On a chilly winter morning in between storms, Valentine and a team of
students boarded the RV/Yellowfin and set out to collect more seafloor
samples along key points of a hot-spot map that they�ve been piecing
together.

As his students sliced and cataloged each layer of mud, they gasped in
wonder at the tiny worms, snails and sea stars that lived so deep under
the sea. They squinted at each tube that came out of the water and laughed
apprehensively when asked about all the chemicals they were possibly
holding in their hands.

�The goal is to collect as much mud as possible so that we don�t have to
come back out every time we have a question,� Valentine explained as the
ship�s mechanical pulley churned for the eighth time that day. �We are
starting to build a really exceptional data set � that will help us
understand the time history of how things were transported, how they were
transformed, and what their ultimate fate is.�

Other scientists have also been chipping away at the many pieces to this
deep-ocean puzzle.

Thursday�s research updates included plans for the next Scripps mapping
expedition, which will scan the seafloor with advanced sonar technology
and take hundreds of thousands of photos. Microbiologists shared their
latest studies into whether deep-sea microbes could possibly help
biodegrade some of the contamination, and chemical oceanographers
discussed the many ways they�ve been trying to identify �fingerprints�
that could help determine where the DDT is coming from � and how and if
it�s moving.

Biological oceanographers, marine ecologists and fisheries scientists also
started to connect some dots on the various organisms they�ve found living
in the contaminated sediment, as well as the midwater species that could
potentially move the chemicals from deeper waters up closer to the
surface.

All of them noted that there were uncomfortably high concentrations of DDT
and DDT-related compounds in the samples they studied. Even the �control�
samples they tried to collect � as a way to compare what a normal sediment
or fish sample farther away from the dumping area might look like � ended
up riddled with DDT.

�This suggests to us, very preliminarily, that there�s some connection
potentially � there�s connectivity in these deep food webs across the
basins and across the system,� said Lihini Aluwihare, a marine chemist at
Scripps.

On top of all this research, the EPA has been developing its own sampling
plan, in collaboration with a number of state and federal agencies, to get
a grasp of the many other chemicals that had been dumped into the ocean.
The hope, officials said, is that the groundbreaking science now underway
on the deep-ocean DDT dumping will ultimately inform how future
investigations of other offshore dump sites � whether along the Southern
California coast or elsewhere in the country � could be conducted.

Mark Gold, an environmental scientist at the Natural Resources Defense
Council who has worked on the DDT problem since the 1990s, said that as he
listened to the latest research discoveries, he couldn�t help but think
that �our nation�s ocean dumpsites all have horrible contamination
problems. And yet they are unmonitored.�

There are also more shallow areas off the Palos Verdes coast and at the
mouth of the Dominguez Channel that have been known DDT hot spots for
decades. Figuring out how to clean up those contaminated areas in an
underwater environment has been its own complicated saga.

For Katherine Pease at Heal the Bay, an environmental group that has been
making sure the public remains engaged on this issue in substantive ways,
these latest revelations have been eye-opening.

This is, after all, what it truly means to live with a �forever� chemical.
After all these decades, scientists are still uncovering new and
unsettling surprises about the full extent of the contamination.

�We�re still grappling with this legacy of treating the ocean as a dumping
ground,� said Pease, Heal the Bay�s science and policy director. �And the
public � whether they�re folks that like to fish ... or people who like to
swim and visit the ocean � we all need to understand the history that went
on, as well as the impacts. And partly that�s to learn ... to make sure
that we�re able to protect our public health, but also to think about how
we are treating the ocean now, as well as into the future.�

https://www.latimes.com/environment/story/2023-03-23/scientists-uncover-
startling-concentrations-of-pure-ddt-along-seafloor-off-l-a-coast